Questions but few answers so opposition leader asks again about council's financial situation

By Neil Speight 11th Mar 2022

Cllr SHane Hebb, left, is accused of not answering his political rival Cllr John Kent's questions
Cllr SHane Hebb, left, is accused of not answering his political rival Cllr John Kent's questions

THURROCK Council's Labour opposition leader Cllr John Kent has questioned the integrity of the authority's ruling Conservative group and the walls of silence they have built around their controversial borrowing to invest policy.

And he challenged them to come up with answers to legitimate questions.

Cllr Kent says: "At the recent budget setting it was confirmed that the council's overall borrowing borrowing is expected to rise to over one and a half billion pounds in the next year, meaning £23 million will be spent on debt repayments.

"Much of that borrowing has been taken out to fund investments - mainly in the solar energy sector - however, the veil of secrecy in which these investments have been cloaked make it difficult to have full confidence in their security."

Cllr Kent has issued a series of public questions after failing to draw answers from portfolio holders during the meeting.

Following a warning issued by the council's chief finance officer Sean Clark that "any investment can result in a capital loss through, for instance, business failure", Cllr Kent raised the issue of the council's investment in Pure World Energy, which is known to be in financial difficulties, and asked how confident the portfolio holder is in the security of that investment.

He then asked about the council's investment with Toucan Energy Holdings.

During a much publicised court case last year, it emerged that the prospectus on which the council invested £145 million contained "clear untruths" and the solar farms bought with the help of that investment had a number of defects that may have reduced their value, meaning the investment may not be repaid in full.

Cllr Kent asked what assessment has been made of the security of that investment?

In the same court case it was revealed that Thurrock Council paid £5 million in "commission" to the individual who arranged the deal. Cllr Kent asked the portfolio holder Cllr Shane Hebb to confirm that he, and the leader of the council, Cllr Rob Gledhill, were aware of that payment.

Finally, Cllr Kent detailed what he described as a 'complex network of companies' that it is believed Thurrock Council has invested in. Many of those companies are undergoing restructures. The council, and others, have objected to those restructures and many have failed to have their accounts signed off.

Cllr Kent asked how confident Cllr Hebb is that the council's investment will be repaid in full.

Though he received responses to all the questions asked on the night, they were wrapped in so much rhetoric and counter criticism actual answers to the specific wording of questions were not forthcoming. Cllr Kent said: "This is a complicated issue but I do believe the Conservatives have borrowed too much, haven't shown sufficient rigour in where they have invested and failed to demonstrate the openness they promised back in 2017. "There are four key questions that need to be answered; "What assessment has been made of security of the council's investments in Pure World Energy? "Given the details revealed during the court case, what assessment has been made of the security of the council's investment in Toucan Energy Holdings? "With many of the companies the council has invested with being restructured and not having their accounts signed off, how confident is the administration that the projected income will be realised and the investment repaid in full? "And, finally, did the portfolio holder and leader of the council know, at the time, of the £5 million commission paid for arranging the council's investments in Toucan Energy Holdings? "In the interests of openness and transparency it is vital that these questions, which went unanswered at the meeting, are answered now."

     

New thurrock Jobs Section Launched!!
Vacancies updated hourly!!
Click here: thurrock jobs

Share:


Sign-Up for our FREE Newsletter

We want to provide thurrock with more and more clickbait-free local news.
To do that, we need a loyal newsletter following.
Help us survive and sign up to our FREE weekly newsletter.

Already subscribed? Thank you. Just press X or click here.
We won't pass your details on to anyone else.
By clicking the Subscribe button you agree to our Privacy Policy.